The best running stores in Indiana
Ranked by real customers — rating weighted by review volume across 13,373 Google reviews. Only shops with 25+ reviews qualify. Updated 2026.
#1 Ultimate Fit Shoes & Home Fitness Equipment
5 ★★★★★ 5,419 reviews · Evansville, IN
Retailer featuring active footwear, plus treadmills, stationary bikes & other home gym essentials.
“I stopped into Ultimate Fit hoping to find a comfortable pair of shoes for my aching feet, and I ended up receiving one of the best customer service experiences I’ve had in a long …” — Cathy
#2 Fleet Feet Mishawaka
4.9 ★★★★★ 1,013 reviews · Mishawaka, IN
Retail chain stocking athletic shoes, apparel & accessories geared toward runners.
“Great customer service. I was greeted immediately and paired up with a very experienced and helpful gentleman named Walt. He was very informative and professional. Learned a lot ab…” — Joshua
#3 Fleet Feet West Lafayette
4.9 ★★★★★ 684 reviews · West Lafayette, IN
Retail chain stocking athletic shoes, apparel & accessories geared toward runners.
“This is the only place I will buy running/athletic shoes. The staff is incredibly knowledgeable and friendly. The measurement system they use is insanely accurate and has saved me …” — Stephanie
#4 Pacers & Racers New Albany
4.9 ★★★★★ 676 reviews · New Albany, IN
Retail store stocking brand-name shoes, apparel & accessories for running & walking.
“I came here at a friend's recommendation. Boy am I glad. My job requires me to walk and stand all day. As soon as I walked in and explained my situation, I was helped by Jeff (as i…” — Ted
#5 Athletic Annex - Nora
4.9 ★★★★★ 515 reviews · Indianapolis, IN
Athletic shoe merchant featuring brand-name sneakers, activewear and gait analysis.
“Treated the C3 (Christina’s Complete Clean) staff to new shoes today! Housecleaning can be very hard on the body! Now fitted in the right shoes for each person, I hope it’s a littl…” — Christina
#6 Fleet Feet
4.7 ★★★★★ 425 reviews · Schererville, IN
Retail chain stocking athletic shoes, apparel & accessories geared toward runners.
“New runner here! I was referred here by a friend. I am so grateful I decided to come here because staff is so helpful! Fleet Feet’s advanced technology helps you find the perfect s…” — Mckaya
#7 Three Rivers Running Company
4.8 ★★★★★ 370 reviews · Fort Wayne, IN
Local specialty shop selling running-friendly footwear and apparel.
“If you are looking for a shoe that is perfect for your stride this is the place to go. They will record you running and diagnose the perfect shoe for you. I came in and a staff mem…” — Grant
#8 Athletic Annex - Fishers
5 ★★★★★ 278 reviews · Fishers, IN
Shoes, apparel, and accessories for active and casual use, plus community events.
“My podiatrist recommended that I visit the Athletic Annex. I have been diagnosed with planter fasciitis in both feet, and tarsal tunnel in my left foot. I’ve had multiple foot surg…” — Mary
#9 Running Vines Winery
4.7 ★★★★★ 319 reviews · Chesterton, IN
“This is such a cute, fun place. They do have a patio if you prefer to sit outside. The staff was very friendly, fun, and helpful. Great service! We ordered a pizza and an appetizer…” — Jacqui
#10 Fleet Feet Fort Wayne
4.7 ★★★★★ 318 reviews · Fort Wayne, IN
Retail chain stocking athletic shoes, apparel & accessories geared toward runners.
“Fort Wayne is blessed to have one of the best Fleet Feet stores in the country, now with two locations. The owner Kevin Croy and his staff do a great job and are very knowledgeable…” — Kevin